Whenever I'm Alone with You (2023, France)

by Guillaume Campanacci & Vesper Egon

The film opens with a warning:

“If you want to watch a romantic comedy, I’m sorry.”

Moments later, a woman sits in a bathtub wearing delicate lace lingerie, and the film lays out a few more... conditions.
Is this a strange film? Perhaps.
The typographic “play” at the beginning immediately brought to mind Godard—and the influence of 1960s Nouvelle Vague aesthetics doesn’t stop there.

As in nearly every film, we have a man. His name is Guillaume. And as in nearly every film, we have a woman. Her name is Tatiana. She’s the one in the tub—into which Guillaume eventually jumps as well.
The scene, accompanied by music, works beautifully.
Then we move on to another moment, where a voiceover introduces Tatiana.

So the film begins after a few scenes… or perhaps it only feels like it begins after a few scenes. Either way, it does begin—but…

Since the film doesn’t rely on traditional cinematic narrative, the viewer is left constantly wondering: what am I seeing, and in what order?
Time skips around, jumping between moments and moods, giving the whole film an episodic feel.

There are tributes to Godard everywhere:
jump cuts, sudden audio dropouts, even entire scenes “toned” in red or blue hues.
It’s as if tricks are sprinkled throughout just for the joy of it—but it works.

Sometimes, we’re firmly in the present. The dialogue flows, at times sharp and witty, as in a memorable scene where Guillaume and Tatiana debate gender roles.
Then we’re back in the bathroom—this time sharing wine in intimate conversation.
The tone shifts into something more like a home video or documentary. In certain scenes, we even see the characters’ thoughts appear as text on screen—a gimmick, sure, but one that actually lands quite nicely.

So what, then, is this film really about?
What does it want to say—if anything?

If a film could be a poem—a prose poem—not a poetic film but a film structured like a poem, this would be it:
floating, compressed, moving by the logic of dreams.
A series of moments strung together in time and tone: people falling in love, breaking up, yearning, desiring.

And yes, in such a poem, there would surely be room for King Alain Delon and David Bowie—perhaps as spiritual artifacts, icons glowing at the edges of memory and longing.

As Marcel Proust once wrote:

“Time passes, and little by little everything that we have spoken in falsehood becomes true.”

Comments

The Night Porter (1974 - Il portiere di notte)

Liliana Cavani – The Night Porter (1974) I wondered what I could write about two people who are “strangers” to each other, yet share a common past. An ugly and horrific past. One was subordinate. The other held power. What are the odds that they would meet again—and would they even recognize each other? One way or another, in Liliana Cavani’s The Night Porter , they meet again. A man and a woman. Lucia, a former concentration camp prisoner, and Max, the former camp commandant. The film feels like a long, dark dream in its weightlessness— a feverish delirium trying desperately to change its nature. I couldn't help but think of New Order’s Bizarre Love Triangle , though in this case, there are only two protagonists. When their eyes meet at the reception desk of Hotel Zur Oper, flashbacks from the past begin to rise slowly to the surface. After the initial shock and what follows, one begins to contemplate the dynamic between Lucia and Max. They become increasingly entangled ...

The Assessment (2024) When a film presents two worlds—an old one and a new one—it inevitably brings to mind George Orwell, and why not Aldous Huxley as well? The Assessment (2024) is not, however, an Orwellian dystopia, although it certainly is a dystopian portrayal—one that is multi-layered, sharp, and refreshing. Mia (Elizabeth Olsen) and Aaryan (Himesh Patel) are a couple living in the controlled reality of the new world, and they wish to adopt a child. The setup seems fine—at least, on the surface. Technology has certainly taken the upper hand over the old world. The foreboding begins when the official Virginia (Alicia Vikander) arrives to assess the couple’s suitability as parents. The tone of the film is tense, at times unsettling, with Emilie Levienaise-Farrouch's brilliant film score subtly floating in the background, enhancing the atmosphere of instability. The visual quality is impressive and polished, and the casting is spot on. Above all, Alicia Vikander’s p...

Poetic Realism in French Cinema INTRODUCTION Two men walk along a dimly lit peninsula. They talk quietly. The air is misty. The sea is barely visible in the background, and further in the distance, a house emerges from the haze. There is something otherworldly, picturesque, and poetic in the atmosphere. This brief description is from the 1938 film Le Quai des brumes ( Port of Shadows ), directed by Marcel Carné. This film is where it all began—my fascination with the style of French cinema that emerged in the mid-1930s, later known as poetic realism . The term itself originates more from literary realism than from cinema. Typically, the protagonists are working-class people, fugitives, criminals, or those living on the fringes of society. Love, its loss, and the presence or nearness of death are ever-present themes. The cynicism and pessimism of poetic realism reflect the past while foreshadowing the future: the rise of fascism, the impact of the Great Depression, and the ons...

Noir Renoir Films

Search This Blog